The Starlight Bar and Grill pt. 1 is about the McWilliams brothers abd their efforts to get their father's restaurant, The Starlight Bar and Grill, up and running again, after their father's death. In the process, a woman, Stephanie Marsh, Carl Jr.s girlfriend, is pushed first to work in the office and then, to fall in love with the younger brother, Scottie, as a way for Carl to make up for ruining his relationship with his high school sweetheart, Elaine Powers.