William Till has set sail for the Caribbean. Tasked with bringing the pirate mastermind, Edward Teach, to justice and driven by an unshakable sense of duty, William is determined to rid the world of Teach's menace and restore peace. But when Teach's retaliation sends William reeling, he's forced to face the ultimate test of duty.

The timeline of this book runs along side the events that occurred in the Tales From Neverland trilogy-including Peter, The Last Pirate, and On Nightmare's Shore. While a standalone book, this story and context would be best understood if the other books are read first.