Penny finds a necklace that she decides to keep, just for a little while, but then starts to believe that the necklace is hers. She does not connect her actions with those of the 'jewel thieves' she has been trying to evict from the park, even though she lies to her friends about how she got the necklace. Pepper helps Penny to understand what she has done is wrong, and that keeping something you have found and steeling are the same thing. She also learns that lying to your friends is wrong, but there are some magical words that can help make things better.