Vietnam took Jerry Fellows away from Minter, WI and returned him in a body bag. Thirty-five years later Matt Bratzman begins to remember a life he lived before he went to Vietnam. In that life he was Jerry Fellows. When DNA testing proves he isn't Matt, he returns to Minter to find out the truth about who is buried in the grave with the name Jerry Fellows on the marker?

Thirty-five years ago, on Christmas Eve, Betsy Connor received a call telling her that her husband was dead. Now widowed for a second time, she receives a Christmas Eve call from the man who was her first love. Can it be possible or is it a clever con game?